Features Catalog Stores Pricing

The Collector

Know every issue. Keep every story. Built for collectors who want evidence, not hype.

Product

Features
Pricing
Catalog
New releases
Store directory

For stores

List your shop
Seller fees

Company

Help and contact
Privacy
Terms
Data sources
Copyright requests

© 2026 The Collector

Catalog data from Metron, the Grand Comics Database and cataloggd, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0. Cover images © their respective publishers, shown to identify each issue.

Sign in Start free

What If...? #51 (1993) · The Collector

Catalog
What If...? (1989)
#51

Marvel#51

What If...?

Previous issue, #50 All issues Next issue, #52

What If...? #51

What If the Punisher Had Become Captain America

Publisher: Marvel
Cover date: July 1993
On sale: May 18, 1993
Cover price: $1.25
Pages: 36
Rating: Approved by the Comics Code Authority

Add to collection Add to wishlist

Editions and variants

Cover, printing and newsstand or direct distribution are what make two copies of one issue different books.

3 recorded

Direct EditionMain
Printing not stated · $1.25

Sources

Grand Comics Database issue 53330

Catalog data from the Grand Comics Database is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0 and was normalized by The Collector. Cover images belong to their publishers.

Frank Castle takes over for a blinded Captain America. But can he stop himself from becoming a ruthless vigilante?

Australian

Printing not stated · Newsstand · AU market · A$1.95

Newsstand

Printing not stated · $1.25

Credits

Writer: Simon Furman
Penciller: Paris Cullins
Inkers: Frank Turner, Dave Cooper
Colorist: Carlos Lopez
Letterer: Janice Chiang
Cover: Art Nichols
Editor: Rob Tokar
Editor in chief: Tom DeFalco

Characters

Avengers [Scarlet Witch
Baron Blood
Beast
Captain America
Count Nefaria
Doc Samson
Falcon
Hammerhead
Henry Gyrich
Iron Man
John Jameson
Kyle Richmond
Nick Fury
Punisher
Richard Diamond
Vision
Wasp
Watcher

No collectors have logged this issue yet.

Value

No value yet

We publish a value only when at least five collectors have recorded an anonymized price for a grade band, and always show how many. Logging what you paid helps.

Available at stores

No stores list this issue right now

Shops on The Collector post their shelves here. Add it to your wishlist and you will hear when a copy shows up.